Mon - Fri: 8:00AM - 5:00PM
Monday – Friday8:00AM - 5:00PM
Saturday Open for MRI
Sunday Closed
Migraine treatment same day as your first appointment.
or
Visit our Healow Portal
Visit our Healow Portal Call 214-619-1910
CALL 214-619-1910

Wernicke’s Aphasia vs Broca’s Aphasia: What Is the Difference?

Sandeep Dhanyamraju MD
Medically reviewed by Sandeep Dhanyamraju
Book appointment
Sandeep Dhanyamraju MD
Medically reviewed by Sandeep Dhanyamraju

Wernicke’s and Broca’s lexicon area damages are two distinct types of lexicon disorders. They arise from damage to specific areas of the brain. These conditions affect the production and comprehension of the lexicon. But they manifest in different ways, highlighting the complexity of human communication.

Understanding the difference between Broca’s and Wernicke’s aphasia is crucial. It’s essential for effective diagnosis and therapy. 

In our Wernicke’s aphasia vs Broca’s aphasia guide, we will examine the distinct characteristics. And we will look at the patterns of impairment associated with each condition. This way, clinicians can tailor interventions to address the specific challenges faced by individuals with conditions.

Understanding Aphasia and Its Different Types

It’s a lexicon disorder. It occurs due to damage to specific brain areas, typically the left hemisphere. Understanding the difference between Broca’s and Wernicke’s aphasia is crucial for accurate diagnosis and treatment. There are some common types of verbal impairment:

  • Broca’s. It’s also known as an expressive or non-fluent type. Difficulties in verbal communication production characterize it. Individuals with it struggle to form words and construct grammatically correct sentences. But comprehension abilities are relatively preserved.
  • Global. It’s a severe form of the condition. There, individuals have significant impairments in both verbal communication production and lexicon comprehension.
  • Anomic. Difficulties in finding and retrieving words characterize it. It often results in pauses, word-finding difficulties, and using alternative words or descriptions.
  • Wernicke’s. It’s also known as the receptive or fluent type. It primarily affects lexicon comprehension. People with Wernicke’s area damage may speak fluently. But their verbal communication is often nonsensical and lacks meaning. They have difficulty understanding spoken and written communication.
  • Transcortical Motor. It’s a type like Broca’s one but with intact repetition skills.
  • Transcortical Sensory. It’s like Wernicke’s type but with preserved repetition skills.
  • Conduction. Impaired repetition abilities characterize it. It’s despite relatively preserved verbal communication production and comprehension skills.
  • Primary Progressive (PPA). It is a neurodegenerative condition where lexicon abilities deteriorate progressively over time.
  • Anomia. It’s a word-finding issue. It is a common symptom in various types of lexicon issues. There, individuals have trouble recalling or retrieving specific words.

an elderly man suffering from headache

Overview of Wernicke’s Aphasia

Wernicke’s area damage is a neurological disorder. It’s characterized by difficulties in understanding and producing meaningful verbal communication. It is caused by damage to the Wernicke’s area. It’s a region in the left hemisphere of the brain that handles lexicon comprehension. This condition can significantly impact an individual’s ability to communicate effectively.

This overview aims to provide a concise understanding of the condition. We will highlight its key characteristics and the impact it has on communication. 

We can gain insight into the experiences of individuals affected by this type of verbal impairment and the importance of appropriate support and therapy for their communication needs.

Language Impairments

Individuals with Wernicke’s verbal impairment experience significant lexicon impairments. One of the key features of this Wernicke’s area damage is the presence of fluent but meaningless communication. The affected individuals can produce a large number of words. But the content and meaning of their lexicon are often disorganized and nonsensical. This phenomenon is also known as “word salad.” Also, they may have difficulty finding the right words or understanding the meaning.

Speech Fluency and Comprehension

One of the characteristics of Wernicke’s area damage is the preservation of communication fluency. Individuals with this condition can speak effortlessly. And they maintain a normal rate of verbal communication. But then its content is typically marked by:

  • Frequent word substitutions.
  • Neologisms (invented words).
  • Jumbled sentence structure.

Despite the seemingly fluent output, their communication lacks coherence. And it fails to convey meaningful messages.

Comprehension of spoken and written communication is also impaired in individuals. They often have difficulty understanding the meaning of words, sentences, and conversations. This can lead to: 

  • Significant challenges in following instructions.
  • Engaging in meaningful conversations.
  • Comprehending written materials.

Overview of Broca’s Aphasia

Broca’s and Wernicke’s areas both handle verbal communication. But Broca’s verbal impairment is a condition where people have trouble speaking fluently. It happens when Broca’s area in the brain gets damaged. This area in the frontal lobe helps with lexicon production and verbal communication.

People with this type of verbal impairment find it hard to find words and put sentences together. They may speak slowly and struggle to form complete phrases or use single words. Despite their difficulty in speaking, they can usually understand what others say.

Like Wernicke’s area block, this one also aims to give a brief understanding of Broca’s verbal impairment and its specifications. We will explain its main features and how it affects communication. This knowledge also highlights the importance of customized interventions and support. It helps to improve their ability to communicate effectively.

Language Impairments

According to our Wernicke’s aphasia vs Broca’s aphasia guide, individuals with Broca’s verbal impairment experience significant lexicon issues. One of the characteristics is the difficulty in forming words. And constructing grammatically correct sentences can be hard. They tend to speak in short, telegraphic phrases or produce halting, effortful verbal communication. Despite their limited communication output, their comprehension of communication remains relatively intact.

Speech Production and Expressive Difficulties

Similar to Wernicke’s areas and other speech disorders, individuals with Broca’s verbal impairment struggle to articulate words. And they may experience difficulty with word finding. A slow, difficult, and effortful manner characterizes their verbal communication. They often omit function words. For example, articles and prepositions. And they rely on content words to convey meaning. This leads to agrammatism. There, sentences lack proper grammar and syntactic structure.

Although expressive abilities are affected, individuals often maintain good comprehension of the lexicon. They can understand the meaning of words, sentences, and conversations. But they may have difficulty comprehending complex or lengthy linguistic structures.

Common Difference Between Broca’s and Wernicke’s Aphasia

Here is the difference between broca’s and wernicke’s aphasia:

  • Lexicon Production. In Broca’s verbal impairment, individuals struggle with verbal communication production. And they have limited output. It’s characterized by halting, effortful communication and difficulty forming grammatically correct sentences. In contrast, individuals with Wernicke’s verbal impairment have fluent communication. But they produce a nonsensical and disorganized lexicon, often called “word salad.”
  • Comprehension. Individuals with Broca’s damage have relatively preserved comprehension. But those with Wernicke’s type experience comprehension difficulties. They struggle to understand the meaning of spoken and written communication. It includes words, sentences, and conversations.
  • Verbal Communication Fluency. According to our Wernicke’s aphasia vs Broca’s aphasia guide, Broca’s damage type is associated with non-fluent speech. A slow rate, limited vocabulary, and impaired articulation mark it. Wernicke’s damage is characterized by fluent communication with a normal rate and intonation. But the content lacks coherence and meaning.
  • Grammar and Syntax. According to our Wernicke’s aphasia vs Broca’s aphasia guide, Broca’s damage often leads to agrammatism. There, individuals have difficulty with grammatical structures and omit function words. In Wernicke’s verbal impairment, grammar, and syntax are usually preserved. But the content of the communication lacks meaningful context.

designation of different areas of the brain

Bottom Line

In summary of our Wernicke’s aphasia vs Broca’s aphasia guide, conditions differ in terms of:

  • Lexicon production.
  • Comprehension.
  • Verbal communication fluency.
  • Grammar.
  • Syntax.

Broca’s verbal impairment is usually characterized by: 

  • Non-fluent verbal communication production. 
  • Preserved comprehension.
  • Grammar difficulties. 

Wernicke’s area damage is usually marked by: 

  • Fluent but meaningless verbal communication.
  • Impaired comprehension.
  • Preserved grammar.

Understanding distinctions between Broca’s and Wernicke’s areas helps in accurate diagnosis and treatment.

FAQs:

How does a person with Broca’s aphasia talk?

A person with Broca’s aphasia typically speaks with great effort. They use short, telegraphic phrases and experience difficulty forming grammatically correct sentences.

What does Wernicke’s aphasia sound like?

It’s characterized by fluent but nonsensical speech. It’s often called “word salad,” where the content lacks coherence and meaning.

What are the differences between Broca’s area and Wernicke’s area?

Broca’s area handles language production. And it’s located in the frontal lobe. Wernicke’s area is usually involved in lexicon comprehension. And it’s in the posterior part of the superior temporal gyrus in the brain’s left hemisphere.

1 Star2 Stars3 Stars4 Stars5 Stars (No Ratings Yet)
Loading...
Be the first to write a review
Lone Star Neurology
4.5
Based on 905 reviews
powered by Google
Edward Medina
Edward Medina
15:34 30 Jun 22
Just such an amazing staff that makes you feel like part of their family. I’ve been going there for over 5 years now... and each visit I get the very best care and treatments that I have ever received in the 20+ years that I’ve been dealing with severe debilitating migraines. Since i started seeing them the number of my migraines has dropped from 15-20 a month to 2-3 every 3 month. I highly recommend them …they will change your life!read more
Daneisha Johnson
Daneisha Johnson
22:20 19 May 22
Dr. Askari was very kind and explained everything so I could understand. The other staff were nice as well. I would... have gave 5 stars but I was a little taken aback when I checked in and had to pay 600.00 upfront. I think that should have been discussed in a appointment confirmation call or email just so I could have been prepared.read more
Jean Cooper
Jean Cooper
16:54 29 Apr 22
I love the office staff they are friendly and very helpful. Dr. JODIE is very caring and understanding to your needs... and wants to help you. I will go back. would recommend Dr. Dr. Jodie to other Patients in a heart beat. The team works well together.read more
Linda M
Linda M
19:40 02 Apr 22
I was obviously stressed, needing to see a neurologist. The staff was so patient and Dr. Ansari was so kind. At one... point he told me to relax, we have time, when I was relaying my history of my condition. That helped ease my stress. I have seen 3 other neurologists and he was the only one who performed any assessment tests on my cognitive and physical skills. At one point I couldn't complete two assessments and got upset and cried. I was told, it's OK. That's why you're here. I was truly impressed, and super pleased with the whole experience!read more
Leslie Durham
Leslie Durham
15:05 01 Apr 22
I've been coming here for about 5 years. The staff are ALWAYS friendly and knowledgeable. The Doctors are the absolute... best!! Jodie Moore is always in such a great mood which is a plus when you are already stressed. Highly recommendedread more
Monica Del Bosque
Monica Del Bosque
14:13 25 Mar 22
Since my first post my thoughts have changed here. It's unfortunate. My doctor and PA were great, but the office staff... is horrible. They never call you back when they say they will, they misinform you, they cause you too much stress wondering what's going on, they don't keep you posted. They never answer the phone. At this point I've left four messages in the last week, and I have sent three messages. Twice from their portal and one direct email. No response. My appointment is on Monday morning at 8:30am, no confirmation on my insurance and what's going on. What the heck is going on, this is ridiculous!I've given up... the stress her office staff has put me through is just not worth it. You can do so much better, please clean house, either change out your office staff, or find a way for them to be more efficient please. You have to do something. This is not how you want to run your practice. It leaves a very bad impression on your business.read more
Ron Buckholz
Ron Buckholz
23:32 23 Mar 22
I was actually pleasantly surprised with this visit! It took me a long time to get the appointment scheduled because no... one answers your phones EVER! After a month, I finally got in, and your staff was warm, friendly, and I was totally impressed! I feel like you will take care of my needs!read more
Steve Nabavi
Steve Nabavi
16:28 16 Mar 22
It was a nice visit. Happy staff doing all they can do to comfort the patients in a very calming environment. You ask... me they are earned a big gold star on the fridge. My only complaint they didn't give me any cookies.read more
Katie Lewis
Katie Lewis
16:10 10 Feb 22
Had very positive appointments with Jodie and Dr. Sheth for my migraine care. Jodie was so fast with the injections and... has so much valuable info. I started to feel light headed during checkout and the staff was SO helpful—giving me a chair, water, and taking me into a private room until I felt better. Highly recommend this practice for migraine patients, they know what they’re doing!!read more
Joshua Martinez
Joshua Martinez
16:02 10 Dec 21
I was scheduled to be checked and just want to say that the staff was fantastic. They were kind and helpful. I was... asked many questions related to what was going on and not once did I feel as though I was being brushed off. The front desk staff was especially great in assisting me. I'm scheduled to go back for a mri and am glad that I'll be going there.read more
Isabel Ivy
Isabel Ivy
21:42 03 Nov 21
I had such a good experience with Lone Star Neurology, Brent my MRI Tech was so awesome and made sure I was very... comfortable during the appointment. He gave me ear plugs, a pillow, leg support and blanket, easiest MRI ever lol 🤣 My 72 hour EEG nurse Amanda was also so awesome. She made sure I was take care of over the 3 days and took her time with the electrodes to make sure it was comfortable for me! Paige was also a huge help in answering all my questions when it came to my test results, and letting me know her honest opinions about how I should go forth with my treatment.read more
Leslie Luce
Leslie Luce
17:37 20 Oct 21
The professionalism and want to help attitude of this office was present from the moment I contacted them. The follow... up and follow through as well as their willingness to find a way to schedule my dad was above and beyond. We visited two offices in the same day with the same experience. I am appreciative of this—we spend a lot of time with doctors and this was top notch start to finish.read more
robert Parker
robert Parker
16:38 16 Apr 21
I love going to this office. The staff is friendly and helpful. The doctor is great. I am getting the best... neurological tests and treatment I have ever had. The only reason I did not give them a 5 star rating is because it is impossible to reach a live person at the office to reschedule appointments. Every time I have tried to get through to the office it says all people are busy and I am sent to a voicemail. If they could get their phone answering fixed, I would give them a strong 5 stars.read more
MaryAnn Hornbaker
MaryAnn Hornbaker
00:26 25 Feb 21
Dr. Harney is an excellent Dr. I found him friendly , personable and thorough. I evidently am an unusual case. ... Therefore he spent a Hugh amount of time educating me. He even gave me literature to further explain my condition and how to follow up. This is something you rarely get from your doctors. So I am more than please with my doctor and his staff.read more
Roger Arguello
Roger Arguello
03:05 29 Jan 21
Always courteous, professional. The staff is very friendly and always work with you to find the best appointment time.... The care team has been great. Always taking the time to listen to your concerns and to find the best treatment.read more
Margaret Rowland
Margaret Rowland
01:12 27 Jan 21
I have been a patient at Lone Star Neurology for several years. Now both my adult daughters also are patients there. I... love Jodie. She is always so prompt whether it is a teleamed call are a visit in the office. She takes the time to explain everything to me and answers all my questions. I am so blessed to have Jodie as my doctor.read more
Susan Miller
Susan Miller
03:01 13 Jan 21
My husband had an accident 5 years ago and Lone Star Neurology has been such a blessing to us with my husbands care.... Jodie Moore is his provider and she is amazing! Jodie is very knowledgeable, caring, and thorough. She takes her time with you, making sure your needs are met and she is happy to answer any questions you may have. Lone Star Neurology’s patients are very lucky to have Jodie providing their care. Thank you Lone Star Neurology and especially Jodie for everything you have done for us. Jodie, you are the best!read more
Windalyn C
Windalyn C
01:32 09 Jan 21
Jodie is wonderful. She is very caring and knowledgeable. I have been to over a dozen neurologists, and none were able... to help me as much as they have here. Thanks!read more
Katie Kordel
Katie Kordel
00:40 09 Jan 21
Jodi Moore, nurse practitioner, is amazing. I have suffered from frequent, debilitating headaches for almost 20 years.... She has provided the best proactive and responsive care I have ever received. My quality of life has been greatly improved by her caring approach and tenacity in finding solutions.read more
Ellie Natsis
Ellie Natsis
15:41 07 Jan 21
I have had the best experience at this neurologist's office! For over a year I have been receiving iv treatments here... each month and my nurse, Bobbie is beyond wonderful!! She's so attentive, knowledgeable, caring, and detail oriented. She makes an otherwise uncomfortable experience much more pleasant and definitely puts me at ease! She also helps me with my insurance,ordering this specialty medication and dealing with the ordering process which is no easy feat.Needless to say, she goes above a beyond in every way and I'm so grateful to this office and to Bobbie for all they do for me!read more
Matt Morris
Matt Morris
15:39 07 Jan 21
Let me start by saying that I have been coming here for years. Due to my autoimmune disease, I am in this office... once every three weeks for multiple hours at a time. The office is very clean and the staff very friendly. My only complaint would be there communication via phone. They aren't the best at responding if you leave a voicemail and expect a call back. I understand that this is prob just due to the sheer number of alls they receive daily. What I can say I like the best about the office are the people. Bobby who handles my infusions is great. I never have any issues with her setting up my infusions. She is very quick to reply to messages sent via text and if she were to leave then my whole opinion of the office may change. I also enjoy people like Matt, Lauren, and Jodi. I appreciate all that they do for me and without this team I'm not sure I would be as happy as I am to visit the office as frequently as I have to. Please ensure that these folks are recognized as they are what makes my visit to this office so tolerable :).read more
More reviews
js_loader

Please, leave your review

review

Write a comment:

Book appointment